A worrying mystery at Villa Park! Why has Garnacho vanished from Emery's plans?
Alejandro Garnacho swapped clubs this summer in search of regular football, but the early weeks of the season have turned into a personal nightmare for the Argentine.
Details: According to Polymarket Sports, Garnacho has played just 31 minutes for Aston Villa this season and has been an unused substitute in the club's last four matches. Unai Emery has admitted the winger is down the pecking order.
The 22-year-old joined Villa on loan from Chelsea in July with a conditional obligation to buy worth around £43 million, a deal designed to relaunch a career that had stalled after his falling out at Manchester United and an underwhelming year in London. Instead, Garnacho is watching from the stands: he was an unused substitute even in the 3-1 Carabao Cup win over Coventry, a match seemingly made for rotation. Emery's blunt assessment that the winger is "a little bit behind" his teammates has only fueled the debate, and the Spanish coach made 14 substitutions across the last three games without once turning to the Argentine. The context makes it stranger still: Villa are struggling badly, with heavy defeats to Brighton and Arsenal and a home loss to Nottingham Forest, yet their most talented attacking reinforcement remains glued to the bench. For Chelsea, watching from afar, the situation is awkward too: if Garnacho does not play, the obligation to buy becomes complicated. The international break may be the reset he needs, but right now the Garnacho project in Birmingham looks anything but convincing.
It's worth noting that Garnacho won the Puskas Award in 2024 for his sensational overhead kick against Everton, a reminder of the talent currently sitting unused.
Reminder: Disaster for Tottenham! De Zerbi suffers another defeat as Aston Villa punish Spurs
Miguel Solomons
Dailysports's expert
